The Godfather vs Goodfellas: The Greatest Mob Movie Debate
Crime/Drama
The Godfather
The aging patriarch of an organized crime dynasty transfers control of his clandestine empire to his reluctant son.
Crime/Drama
Goodfellas
The story of Henry Hill and his life in the mob, covering his rise through the ranks of organized crime and his eventual fall.
Our Verdict
This is cinema's greatest debate without a clear answer. The Godfather is the more formally perfect film — a cathedral of American cinema. Goodfellas is the more exciting, viscerally alive film. If you're watching one, watch both: they represent the full spectrum of what the crime genre can achieve.
The Godfather vs Goodfellas — Head to Head
Watch The Godfather if…
Watch The Godfather if you want the most perfectly crafted American film — operatic, majestic, and unforgettable.
Watch Goodfellas if…
Watch Goodfellas if you want the most thrilling, kinetic, and darkly funny crime film ever made.
Can't Decide? Watch Together and Settle It.
Use FlicksTogether to swipe on both options with your partner. When you both pick the same one, you have your answer — and your plans for tonight.
Try FlicksTogether Free